Skip to main content

MSS 99-1

The Papers of Donald K. Duvall

Overview

Judicial and Professional papers that pertain to Mr. Duvall's tenure as Administrative Law Judge and as attorney specializing in Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930 (1936-1996).

Dates
1930-1996 [Inclusive]
Extents
5.5 Cubic Feet (14 archival boxes)

Scope & Contents

Mr. Duvall’s Papers consist of cases and other materials pertaining to his tenure as an Administrative Law Judge and later as an attorney to Kenyon and Kenyon, working with Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930. The papers are divided in two series: 1. Cases where he acted as a judge on section 337 matters. 2. Cases where he was an attorney for the plaintiff. The most important case in this section is the DRAMs [Certain Dynamic Random Access Memories Components]. The investigation was instituted by the International Trade Commission on March 19, 1986, in response to a complaint filed on behalf of Texas Instruments, Inc., alleging a violation of section 337 in the importation of certain dynamic random access memories (DRAMs) alleged to infringe one or more of ten patents owned by Texas Instruments.” (A DRAM is “monolithic integrated memory circuit containing thousands of storage cells (bits), each of which usually contains a transistor and a capacitor.”) That the “importation and sale constitute unfair methods of competition and unfair acts by reason of infringement of certain claims of ten U.S. Patents owned by TI.” That this competition has “the effect to destroy or substantially injure an efficiently and economically operated domestic industry.” There were nineteen respondents. Nine Japanese companies, including Matsushita Electric Industrial CO., Hitachi, Ltd., Toshiba Corporation, Mitsubishi Electric Corporation, et al.; two Korean companies, Samsung Company, Ltd. and Samsung Semiconductor and Telecommunications Co., Ltd.; and eight U.S. companies. On March 23, 1987, TI announced DRAMs settlements with six of the Japanese companies, and was paid $134 million (Southwest Newswire. March 23, 1987. Lexis Nexis ).

Collection Description

  •  
    Biographical / Historical
  •  
    Immediate Source of Acquisition
fileAutomatic Crankpin Grinders 337-60/ALG Duvall ID, 1979MSS 99-1, Box 1
fileAttache Cases 337-49, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 1
fileBraiding Machines 337-130, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 1
fileCard Data Imprinters 337-104, 1981MSS 99-1, Box 1
file337 Cases [31, 35, 36, 42, 46, 47, 51, 53, 54, 57, 59, 59, 61, 62, 65, 71, 73, 80, 88, 103, 604, 702, 714], 1978-1980MSS 99-1, Box 1
fileCases-Judges and Counsel, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 1
fileCleaners [Chlorofluorohydrocarbon Dry-cleaning Process, Machines and Components] 337-84, 1981MSS 99-1, Box 1
fileCoat Hanger Rings 337-70, 1980MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileCombination Locks 337-45, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileCopper Rod 337-52, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileCorn Poppers 337-101, 1981MSS 99-1, Box 2
file337 Decisions, 1981-1982MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileDOT Matrix Line Printers 337-154, 1983MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileDoxycyline 337-3, 1978-1981MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileFabricated Steel Plates from Japan 337-50, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileFIA [Flow Injection Analysis] 337-151, 1984MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileFingerprint [Automated Identification System] 337-156, 1983MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileFungicides 337-128, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileGemstones [Synthetic] 337-50, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileGlasses [Novelty] 337-55, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 2
fileGrinding Machines 337-95, 1981MSS 99-1, Box 3
fileHeadboxes and Papermaking 337-82, 1980MSS 99-1, Box 3
fileLuggage Products 337-39 (TEO), 1978-1979MSS 99-1, Box 3
fileJustice Department Comments, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 3
fileMicrocarriers 337-129, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 3
fileMiscellaneous 337 and Trade Papers, 1980-1983MSS 99-1, Box 3
fileMonumental Wood Windows 337-40, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 3
filePaint Spray Pumps 337-90, 1980MSS 99-1, Box 4
filePoultry [Cut Up Machines] 337-159, 1983MSS 99-1, Box 4
filePoultry Disk Picking Machines 337-78, 1980MSS 99-1, Box 4
filePre-Hearing Orders and Procedures (CAB & ITC), 1984MSS 99-1, Box 4
filePressure Pads 337-48, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 4
filePublic Interest Factor, 1981, 1990MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileRoller Units 337-44, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileRoto-Photo [Rotable Photographs and Card Display Units and Components] 337-74, 1980MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileSandwich Panels [Molded-in sandwich Panel Inserts and Methods for their Installation] 337-99, 1981MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileScanner and Gamma Camera Medical Diagnostic Imaging Apparatus 337-123, 1982-1983MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileScrew Anchors 337-158, 1983MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileShellbrim Hats 337-86, 1980MSS 99-1, Box 4
file[Skinless Sausage Casings] 337-148] Letters Rogatory, 1984MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileSneakers [with Fabric Uppers and Rubber Soles] 337-118, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileSkateboards and Platforms 337-37, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileSurveying Devices 337-68, 1979MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileThermometer Sheath Packages 337-56, 1978MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileTile Setters 337-41, 1979MSS 99-1, Box 4
fileTrash Pumps [Centrifugal] 337-43, 1979MSS 99-1, Box 5
fileTurning Machines File 337-72, 1980MSS 99-1, Box 5
fileVacuum Bottles 337-108, 1980-1983MSS 99-1, Box 5
fileVehicles [Certain Miniature, Battery Operated, All Terrain Wheeled Vehicles] 337-122, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 5
fileVideo Matrix Display Systems 337-75, 1980-1984MSS 99-1, Box 5
fileWelders [Certain Hand-Operated, Gas Operated Welding, Cutting and Heating Equipment and Component Parts] 337-132, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 5
fileWoodstoves 337-92, 1981MSS 99-1, Box 5
seriesSeries II
fileAdduci v. Code Alarm, CA-94-0418 (GK), 1993-1995MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileAutomotive Transmission Shifters 337-207, 1984MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileCCM [Crystalline Cefadroxil Monohydrate] Complaint and other Pleadings 337-293, 1989MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileCertain Sputtered Carbon Coated Computer Disks and Products Containing Same, Including Disks Drives 337-350, 1993MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileDEC [ Notice of Commission Decision on Review of Initial Determination and Issuance of Limited Temporary Exclusion Order], 1985MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileDILTIAZEM 337-349, 1993MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileDRAMS [Certain Dynamic Random Access Memories Components Thereof and Products Containing the Same] 337-242 , 1986-1987MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileDRAMS due Process, 1986-1987MSS 99-1, Box 6
fileDRAMS Duvall’s Memos, 1986MSS 99-1, Box 7
fileDRAMS - Finnegan [Investigative Report], 1987MSS 99-1, Box 7
fileDRAMS - Finnegan Matter, 1996MSS 99-1, Box 7
fileDRAMS - ITC Initial Determination, Injury, Domestic Industry, 1986-1987MSS 99-1, Box 7
fileDRAMS Initial Determination, 1989MSS 99-1, Box 7
fileDRAMS Miscellaneous Documents, n.d.MSS 99-1, Box 8
fileDRAMS Motions and Orders, 1986-1987MSS 99-1, Box 8
fileDRAMS Orders, 1986MSS 99-1, Box 8
fileDRAMS - TI [Texas Instruments], 1986MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileDRAMS - TI Due Process in #242, 1985MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileDRAMS 337 #312, 1990MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileDRAMS 337#335, 1995MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileGrain Oriented silicon Steel, 1988-1990MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileGlick Client; Rousell-Uclaf-Heller; SGS-Thompson 337-337, 1988-1992MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileGremlins [Character Depictions] 337-201, 1986MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileITC [International Trade Commission] / 337 Complaints, 1991-1994MSS 99-1, Box 10
fileITC/337 Docket/ Notices, 1983-1987MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileITC Rules and Regulations, 1988MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileKenyon & Kenyon 337 Information Requests, 1988-1996MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileMIPS [Computer Systems] and Mocatta Metals, 1986MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileMiscellaneous Cases, 1987-1988, 1994MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileSection 337 Constitutionality/Ogawa Representation, 1988-1990MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileMoscowitz File, 1992MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileOptical Waveguide Fibers 337-#189, 1985MSS 99-1, Box 12
filePlastic Encapsulated Integrated Circuits 337 #315, 1991MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileSection 337 Amendments (Proposed), 1990MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileSection 337 Appeals, 1983-1991MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileSection 337 Attorney Disqualification and Duty of Candor, 1981-1989MSS 99-1, Box 12
fileSection 337 Cases, 1986MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Constitutionality/Ogawa Representation, 1988-1990MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Developments, 1990MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Digests, 1986-1991MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Exclusion Orders - Temporary, 1982MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Interlocutory Review, 1976, 1985MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Miscellaneous, 1988MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Miscellaneous and Reform Act of 1974, 1930-1977MSS 99-1, Box 13
fileSection 337 Modifications/Most Significant, 1991MSS 99-1, Box 14
fileSection 337 P.O. [Protective Order] Issue #337, #335, 1991-1993MSS 99-1, Box 14
fileSection 337 Related Matters, 1976-1996MSS 99-1, Box 14
fileSection 337 “status and Future Prospects of section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930". Conference presented at American Conference Institute, NYC, 1994MSS 99-1, Box 14
fileSickle Guards 337 #247, 1986-1987MSS 99-1, Box 14
fileVolvo - Anthelices 337 #318, 1990MSS 99-1, Box 14
fileUSSR Law of Inventions Proposals, 1991MSS 99-1, Box 14
fileZeitler/ Jepson v. Makita, 1992MSS 99-1, Box 14
English